How to Store Maple Syrup
To store maple syrup properly, refrigerate or freeze it after opening. To maintain the color and flavor of maple syrup, always store it in glass containers, never plastic - even if unopened! When stored in plastic, the syrup will darken over time due to oxygen permeating through the plastic. Read more about glass vs. plastic by clicking here.
If you have maple syrup in plastic jugs, keep them in a cool, dry location to help preserve the color and flavor. Although it does take some effort, you may want to consider repackaging your maple syrup into glass bottles. Read the section below to find out how.
Maple syrup is resistant to spoiling because of the high sugar content. It will last indefinitely if stored properly. Problems can occur though. You may see a build-up of crystals on the bottom of the bottle, or you may find a layer of mold on the top. Read below to learn how both of these issues can be resolved.
Maple Syrup Crystals
If your maple syrup container is starting to look like Superman’s Crystal Cave, then the sugar content of the syrup is too high and crystals are slowly forming. The crystals aren’t bad, so don't worry. They are actually delicious if you can get them out of the container. Hot water can help with that.
You can resolve the crystallization issue by re-boiling the maple syrup and adding some water to bring the sugar content back to the correct range. That’s probably more effort than it’s worth, but see the section below on adjusting sugar content below if you want to give it a try.
Moldy Maple Syrup
Maple syrup may get moldy if left out of the refrigerator for a long time. One cool thing about maple syrup is that the sugar content is so high that mold doesn’t grow inside the syrup; it’s only on the top surface. So don’t throw it out – the maple syrup can be saved!
For generations, Vermonters have skimmed or strained off the mold, boiled, and then merrily poured the maple syrup onto their pancakes. Is that OK? Probably. But like the five-second rule, I’m sure it’s not the “proper” recommendation. If you’re concerned about mold, you can reheat the syrup to kill any mold or bacteria that might be lingering in your syrup. The most recent food safety guidelines today say that some types of mold may not be killed by re-heating the syrup. They recommend that moldy syrup should be discarded.
Maybe I'm old-fashioned, but I sticking with the skim & boil method that has been used for generations. See below for how to heat it, and how to adjust the sugar content as required.
Re-Heating Maple Syrup
In the sugarhouse, the finished maple syrup is heated to between 180 and 200°F. Then the bottles are filled to the top, an air-tight cap is secured, and the bottles are laid on their sides to kill any bacteria hanging out on the lids.
Re-heating your syrup to 180°F will kill any mold or bacteria in your syrup and make it safe to eat. The sugar content will increase a little bit as some of the water evaporates from the maple syrup, but this probably won’t be an issue for most folks. The syrup may be a little extra sweet and may have a slightly thicker mouth-feel. The concern would be if it becomes so sweet that crystals start to form. If you’re at all concerned, read the section below on how to check and adjust the sugar content of your syrup.
CAUTION: when you heat maple syrup, don’t take your eyes off it. The pot will go from hot to boiling over as soon as you look away. Maple syrup bubbles will rise and flow over the edge of the pot and make a serious mess of your stove. Make sure to have butter or cooking oil at the ready. The oil breaks the surface tension, and will quickly knock down the bubbles. It doesn’t take much – you could barely touch a fork to the butter and likely have more than enough. Seriously, like 1/100th of a teaspoon type amount. It’s pretty amazing!
How to Adjust the Sugar Content of Maple Syrup
When bottled in a Vermont sugarhouse, maple syrup should be cooked until the sugar content is 66.9%. In Canada and some US states, the minimum sugar content is a little bit lower at 66.0%. That 0.9% sugar may not sound like a lot, but it’s one of the reasons why Vermont maple syrup tastes just a little bit better than most others!
Your target sugar content is 66.9%: too high and you may get crystals; too low and the risk of mold increases.
Unless you happen to have a syrup hydrometer kicking around in the kitchen utensil drawer you’ll need a candy thermometer for this. You don’t want to use a digital probe meat thermometer because it won’t work well in a pot of maple syrup full of boiling bubbles.
Start by boiling plain water. Let it get to a rolling boil for a few minutes and then check the temperature. Water boils at about 212°F; however, that changes with the barometric pressure. In the sugarhouse, thermometers have an adjustable set point to adjust each day. For your purposes, just note the exact temperature of the boiling water.
Next, find a sturdy pot with high sides that is small enough to ensure you have about an inch and a half or so of maple syrup in the bottom. Remember the warning about boiling over, and keep that butter handy to knock down the bubbles when they inevitably begin to boil over. And never take your eye off the boiling syrup!
To hit the 66.9% sugar content, you need your syrup to boil at 7.5°F above the temperature of the boiling water. It’s a sensitive measurement: 7.1°F over the boiling water point would result in maple syrup that is 66.0% sugar content. Somewhere in the 7-8°F should work well. So if your water boiled at 212.5°F, then your syrup will be properly adjusted when it boils at 212.5 + 7.5 = 220°F. As you heat the maple syrup, keep stirring to ensure the heat is evenly spread throughout the pot.
If your maple syrup is at a full boil, but is less than the target temperature, keep boiling it. You’ll need to raise the sugar content by evaporating off some of the water. When it gets close to being maple syrup you’ll notice a change in the bubbles. The bubbles on the surface will grow larger and larger as the sugar content increases. Before you know it, the multitudes of tiny bubbles will begin to join into large bubbles that may be an inch or two across as they rise to the surface. It can be a little mesmerizing like driving in a snowstorm at night, so stay focused!
If your maple syrup is at a full boil, but exceeds the target temperature, you need to add a little water to bring down the sugar content. Start with a tablespoon or so. Add the water, stir, wait a couple of minutes, and then check the temperature. Continue to add more water to bring down the boiling temperature until you hit your target. Don’t worry if you go too far because you can simply wait for the water to evaporate and the boiling temperature will go back up.
Once you’re satisfied that the sugar content is where you want it to be, turn it off and cover it so that no more water evaporates. Now you have a couple of options: put it in a container to be refrigerated or frozen; or, put it in a container designed for canning hot liquids. Glass Mason jars with nice new lids work well. Just fill the jar with syrup that is between 180 and 200°F, put on the lid, and tip it on its side for a minute to kill any bacteria on the lid.
Now you’re good to store that maple syrup indefinitely. Enjoy!